Amateur ExtraE9B11

What is a disadvantage of decreasing the number of wire segments in an antenna model below 10 segments per half-wavelength?

C
Answer
Antennas and transmission lines
Type
A
Ground conductivity will not be accurately modeled
B
The resulting design will favor radiation of harmonic energy
C
The computed feed point impedance may be incorrect
D
The antenna will become mechanically unstable

Answer Notes

In antenna modeling software utilizing the Method of Moments, simulation accuracy depends heavily on how finely the antenna wires are divided into segments. A widely accepted rule of thumb is to use a minimum of 10 to 20 segments per half-wavelength. If you decrease the number of segments below 10 per half-wavelength, the mathematical model becomes too coarse to accurately capture the rapidly changing current distribution along the wire. The most immediate and noticeable error resulting from this low resolution is an incorrectly computed feed point impedance. Distractors involving mechanical stability are incorrect because segmenting is a purely mathematical software construct, not a physical building technique.
Previous · E9B10
What is the principle of a Method of Moments analysis?
Next · E9C01
What type of radiation pattern is created by two 1/4-wavelength vertical antennas spaced 1/2-wavelength apart and fed 180 degrees out of phase?