Amateur ExtraE9D03
What is the most efficient location for a loading coil on an electrically short whip?
A
Answer
Antennas and transmission lines
Type
A
Near the center of the vertical radiator
B
As low as possible on the vertical radiator
C
At a voltage maximum
D
At a voltage null
Answer Notes
When making an electrically short whip resonant, a loading coil is used to cancel out the antenna's capacitive reactance. The efficiency of the antenna depends heavily on where this coil is placed, as energy lost to heat in the coil reduces radiated power.
Placing the coil near the center of the vertical radiator is the most efficient practical compromise. Placing it at the base is mechanically easier but highly inefficient because the RF current is highest at the base, leading to significant I^2R (resistive) heat losses.
Conversely, placing the coil too high on the whip requires a much larger coil with more turns to achieve the necessary inductance. This greatly increases the coil's internal resistance, offsetting any efficiency gains and making the antenna mechanically top-heavy.
Previous · E9D02
How can two linearly polarized Yagi antennas be used to produce circular polarization?
Next · E9D04
Why should antenna loading coils have a high ratio of reactance to resistance?